(Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
+4
Federation of Antanares
Ireland
Texania
Atletius
8 posters
Page 1 of 1
(Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
As you are all well aware, the current legislative system calls for a debating period before a voting period. This works well for most situations, however there are cases this should not have to happen. For example in cases of Regional Danger (OOC ie zombies thing) and conflict, for example the Regornia Crisis, were a decisive international action is needed as quickly as possible.
Atletius proposes there be a system out in place to allow some pieces of legislation to go straight to vote, rather than waste time debating.
If there is support for this idea we will draft a bill for it.
Atletius proposes there be a system out in place to allow some pieces of legislation to go straight to vote, rather than waste time debating.
If there is support for this idea we will draft a bill for it.
Atletius- Powerbroker
- Posts : 274
Join date : 2013-11-04
Location : United Kingdom
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Atletius wrote:As you are all well aware, the current legislative system calls for a debating period before a voting period. This works well for most situations, however there are cases this should not have to happen. For example in cases of Regional Danger (OOC ie zombies thing) and conflict, for example the Regornia Crisis, were a decisive international action is needed as quickly as possible.
Atletius proposes there be a system out in place to allow some pieces of legislation to go straight to vote, rather than waste time debating.
If there is support for this idea we will draft a bill for it.
Isn't this type of bill more apropriate to be voted on by parliament?
Texania- Potential World Power
- Posts : 641
Join date : 2013-07-25
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
This is just consultations. Most likely a bill proposing something along this lines would have to have to go through parliament yes, maybe even the Council too. But this is just for discussions.
Atletius- Powerbroker
- Posts : 274
Join date : 2013-11-04
Location : United Kingdom
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
I think is not necessary a bill or law about. The speaker of the parliament, in the case of bill that must enact for the situations described by Atletius, can eliminate the debating period and star immediately the voting period.
Federation of Antanares- Potential World Power
- Posts : 580
Join date : 2013-07-14
Location : Roma, Italy
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Atletius wrote:This is just consultations. Most likely a bill proposing something along this lines would have to have to go through parliament yes, maybe even the Council too. But this is just for discussions.
Well doing so will be a violation of Constitution, but to evade that, since the Council forms part from the Parliament which can always be dissolved via no confidence vote from Parliament, and since no one can determine which is emergency or not,
Any member state of Parliament (Council as well) can seek for an emergency action from the WA Council, provided that such emergency act is UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED by the entire WA Council and has no existing international law to base upon citing emergency.
And to avoid abuse of power, if ever so, the WA Court of Justice will have the power to VETO that emergency act via UNANIMOUS VOTE from the court members.
What do you think?
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Great Eurussia wrote:Atletius wrote:This is just consultations. Most likely a bill proposing something along this lines would have to have to go through parliament yes, maybe even the Council too. But this is just for discussions.Well doing so will be a violation of Constitution, but to evade that, since the Council forms part from the Parliament which can always be dissolved via no confidence vote from Parliament, and since no one can determine which is emergency or not,Any member state of Parliament (Council as well) can seek for an emergency action from the WA Council, provided that such emergency act is UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED by the entire WA Council and has no existing international law to base upon citing emergency.And to avoid abuse of power, if ever so, the WA Court of Justice will have the power to VETO that emergency act via UNANIMOUS VOTE from the court members.What do you think?
I do believe that what you are proposing has a serious flaw. If a bill against a certain nation, such as a global embargo, were proposed, and that certain nation is in the council, then he could vote against and buy himself time, even if the rest of the WA wants to embargo that nation.
Texania- Potential World Power
- Posts : 641
Join date : 2013-07-25
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
- Spoiler:
- Texania wrote:Great Eurussia wrote:Atletius wrote:This is just consultations. Most likely a bill proposing something along this lines would have to have to go through parliament yes, maybe even the Council too. But this is just for discussions.Well doing so will be a violation of Constitution, but to evade that, since the Council forms part from the Parliament which can always be dissolved via no confidence vote from Parliament, and since no one can determine which is emergency or not,Any member state of Parliament (Council as well) can seek for an emergency action from the WA Council, provided that such emergency act is UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED by the entire WA Council and has no existing international law to base upon citing emergency.And to avoid abuse of power, if ever so, the WA Court of Justice will have the power to VETO that emergency act via UNANIMOUS VOTE from the court members.What do you think?
I do believe that what you are proposing has a serious flaw. If a bill against a certain nation, such as a global embargo, were proposed, and that certain nation is in the council, then he could vote against and buy himself time, even if the rest of the WA wants to embargo that nation.
Well it is not what I thought of actually. I was just thinking of balancing the power in exercising that emergency act. But if that is the case, that is politics in the international level I would say.
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Texania wrote:Great Eurussia wrote:Atletius wrote:This is just consultations. Most likely a bill proposing something along this lines would have to have to go through parliament yes, maybe even the Council too. But this is just for discussions.Well doing so will be a violation of Constitution, but to evade that, since the Council forms part from the Parliament which can always be dissolved via no confidence vote from Parliament, and since no one can determine which is emergency or not,Any member state of Parliament (Council as well) can seek for an emergency action from the WA Council, provided that such emergency act is UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED by the entire WA Council and has no existing international law to base upon citing emergency.And to avoid abuse of power, if ever so, the WA Court of Justice will have the power to VETO that emergency act via UNANIMOUS VOTE from the court members.What do you think?
I do believe that what you are proposing has a serious flaw. If a bill against a certain nation, such as a global embargo, were proposed, and that certain nation is in the council, then he could vote against and buy himself time, even if the rest of the WA wants to embargo that nation.
Firstly, the court can declare that the said individual is temporarily void of their duties should the offense be serious enough, and secondly, if the fear of such an event occurring is merited, then attach a clause to the bill stating that an individual nation on the council must abstain if there is a conflict of interest.
Europe and Asia- Emerging Power
- Posts : 881
Join date : 2013-03-13
Age : 49
Location : Ann Arbor, MI
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
The idea of Eurussia is good, and it's even better with the clauses proposed by Eurasia. I believe it could be interesting to put it into a bill (or something similar).
New Tarajan- Recognized Power
- Posts : 1340
Join date : 2013-06-23
Location : Rome, Italy
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Eurussias idea is good and so is Eurasias amendment. With your permission I will use these for the creation of a Bill in this matter.
Atletius- Powerbroker
- Posts : 274
Join date : 2013-11-04
Location : United Kingdom
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Atletius wrote:Eurussias idea is good and so is Eurasias amendment. With your permission I will use these for the creation of a Bill in this matter.
I also support the proposal of Eurasia.
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Would a bill for Eurussias + Eurasias proposals have to go through Parliament or the Council
Atletius- Powerbroker
- Posts : 274
Join date : 2013-11-04
Location : United Kingdom
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
I believe it doesn't matter.Atletius wrote:Would a bill for Eurussias + Eurasias proposals have to go through Parliament or the Council
Re: (Consultations) Emergency Legislation/No Debating Period Bills
Atletius wrote:Would a bill for Eurussias + Eurasias proposals have to go through Parliament or the Council
Yes of course. Finalizing a bill from the Council being forwarded to the Parliament will give the proposal a strong chance of passage since it has been endorsed by the executive branch. And likely gain yes votes.
Just make a statement that it was endorsed by the WA Council.
Similar topics
» (Dismissed) Legislation Act
» (Dismissed) WA Inter-Regional Commission Act
» (Consultations) Defender Region
» (Consultations) Electing World Assembly Delegate
» (Consultations) Outer Space Code of Conduct
» (Dismissed) WA Inter-Regional Commission Act
» (Consultations) Defender Region
» (Consultations) Electing World Assembly Delegate
» (Consultations) Outer Space Code of Conduct
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum